Back to forum
Verbal·Craft and Structure·Text Structure and Purpose
medium
Some researchers hypothesize that the species inhabiting the island of Grande Terre are members of clades that inhabited nearby islands before Grande Terre emerged 37 million years ago. While Anna Papadopoulou et al. found that the crown age (the age of the most recent common ancestor of all living and extinct species in the clade) is 59.9 million years for Grande Terre’s clade of leaf beetles, most studies of the island’s clades have reported more recent crown ages: Peter Arensburger et al., for example, found that the crown age of Grande Terre’s clade of cicadas is 8.9 million years.
Which choice best describes the function of the underlined portion in the text as a whole?
A
It explains why a finding that may appear to support a hypothesis introduced earlier in the text actually weakens that hypothesis.
B
It presents a discrepancy between two studies’ results that the text later implies is due to one set of results being inaccurate.
C
It concedes that there is some evidence consistent with a hypothesis that the text goes on to suggest is largely unsupported.
D
It acknowledges that there is compelling evidence both for and against a hypothesis presented earlier in the text.