Back to forum
Verbal·Expression of Ideas·Rhetorical Synthesis
medium
While researching a topic, a student has taken the following notes:
  • The deep, sustained sound that some sand dunes produce when sand slides down their surface is called booming.
  • The waveguide model proposes that booming occurs when sound waves traveling through avalanching surface sands move more slowly than those in the air above and in the firmer sand below.
  • These slower sound waves become trapped between the two faster layers, resonating until they build into a sustained boom.
  • In the summer of 2008, researchers measured slower- and faster-moving waves in the actively booming Dumont Dunes in California’s Mojave Desert.
  • In the winter of 2008, these dunes were silent.
  • Winter rain raised the moisture content of the surface sand and the velocity of the sound waves moving through it, eliminating any speed differential.
The student wants to connect the winter result to the waveguide model of booming. Which choice most effectively uses relevant information from the notes to accomplish this goal?
A
The Dumont Dunes in California’s Mojave Desert were actively booming in the summer of 2008 but silent in the winter of 2008.
B
The absence of winter booming supports the claim that rain removes the necessary speed difference.
C
The lack of winter booming, when the surface sand’s sound waves sped up to match those in the air above and in the denser sand below, fits the model’s claim that a speed differential is required for booming.
D
The finding that the dunes did not boom during the winter seemingly contradicts the model’s claim that sound waves on a dune’s surface travel at the same speed as those in the air above and the sand below.