Back to forum
Verbal·Expression of Ideas·Rhetorical Synthesis
medium
While researching a topic, a student has taken the following notes:
  • At Site L, a ceramic style called comb-impressed ware occurs in layers dated 3200–3000 years ago.
  • At Site M, 90 km away, the same style occurs in layers dated 3100–2900 years ago.
  • At Site N, between L and M, the style occurs in layers dated 3050–2850 years ago.
  • The dates overlap substantially and each range has an uncertainty of about ±80 years.
The student wants to make a cautious claim about the direction in which the style spread. Which choice most effectively uses relevant information from the notes to accomplish this goal?
A
The pottery style certainly originated at Site L and spread through Site N to Site M.
B
The style moved from Site M to Site L because of their positions.
C
Because the earliest estimated range is at Site L, the style may have appeared there first, but the overlapping date ranges and dating uncertainty prevent a confident reconstruction of its direction of spread.
D
The overlapping dates prove that all three sites adopted the style in exactly the same year.