Back to forum
Verbal·Craft and Structure·Cross-Text Connections
medium
Text 1
After beavers were reintroduced to a broad valley in western Colorado, their dams slowed spring runoff and kept adjacent soils moist through late summer. Ecologists studying the site argue that beaver restoration can make stream ecosystems more resilient during drought.
Text 2
A study of beaver dams in steep, confined valleys found much smaller increases in water storage. Several dams in those valleys also failed during intense runoff. The study’s authors conclude that the effects of beaver restoration depend strongly on valley shape and stream conditions.
Based on the texts, how would the authors of Text 2 most likely respond to the conclusion presented in Text 1?
A
By agreeing that the conclusion is plausible but emphasizing that it may not apply equally in all landscapes
B
By arguing that beavers never increase water storage during drought
C
By claiming that the Colorado study measured soil moisture incorrectly
D
By agreeing that valley shape has no effect on the success of beaver restoration