Back to forum
Verbal·Craft and Structure·Text Structure and Purpose
medium
Using hydrogen produced with renewable energy (green hydrogen) can help reduce a country’s industrial carbon emissions, but scaling to meet growing demand is contingent on having sufficient space for renewable energy infrastructure. Assuming a scenario in which 10% coverage of currently eligible land by such infrastructure is feasible, researchers calculated a scarcity factor (with values above 1 indicating insufficient land) for the United Kingdom, France, and China by comparing the amount of land required for electricity production adequate to the country’s projected 2050 demand for green hydrogen with the amount of available land. A student reviews the findings and suggests that in the given scenario, those countries could meet the demand with solar energy alone but not with wind alone.
Which choice best describes the extent to which the student’s claim is supported by data from the graph?
A
The scarcity factors imply that all three countries will produce more hydrogen per unit of land by using only solar energy than by using only wind energy, which suggests that the solar coverage scenario is more feasible than the wind coverage scenario; therefore, the student’s claim is fully supported.
B
France has the lowest scarcity factor for wind among the three countries, suggesting that it will likely need to supplement the use of wind energy with the use of solar energy; therefore, the student’s claim is not supported for France but is for the United Kingdom and China.
C
The scarcity factors indicate that although France and China would have the capacity to use only solar energy but not only wind energy to meet green hydrogen demands, the United Kingdom would not have the capacity to meet demands using either solar or wind energy; therefore, the student’s claim is only supported for France and China.
D
The scarcity factors indicate that even though solar energy installations require less land than wind energy installations do, none of the countries will be able to dedicate 10% of available land for solar energy use; therefore, the student’s claim isn’t supported for any of the three countries.